|
Someone's gotta represent CALTAF in Nemours |
|
Run time in Nemours |
|
Joan of Arc...hows that for history? |
|
Beautiful |
|
This is the way I like to explore, via my running shoes |
|
Its spring already, and when I come home, I get to do spring all over again! |
|
Can anyone understand this? Its freezing instructions from our fridge... |
|
This is what I call CHEESE pizza |
|
Recess at my school |
|
I imagine he just says "OMG OMG OMG" this is the coolest playroom ever |
|
Delicious baguette sandwich outside of Chateau Fountainebleau |
|
Only run through Paris when you have enough money for the metro home...its a big city |
The Cultural and
Educational Context of TAB
Nemours is
a dream. I love living in Nemours. The canals seem endless. The baguettes are
always soft. The weather is warming. But teaching is not getting any easier.
French culture is not anything like Canadian culture, not to mention
pedagogical culture. However all is not lost, France is still worth reflection,
and in those reflections my beliefs are strengthened.
It is
painfully obvious that the French education system is in the dark ages, it still
operates within the factory model of education. The children sit in rows, fill
in the boxes in their work books and paste work sheets into the blank pages.
The children engage in rote memorization of facts and regurgitate those facts
in front of the blackboards. The children have very little, to no, access to
technology in the classroom, LAWN would be considered a terrible idea, allowing
children to access the internet on school time, preposterous! It feels as
though education is about learning dates of events rather than the impact that
event has on their life at this point in time. Education is about completion
rather than creativity. Today my TAB partner and I had the children draw
monsters to work on English colours. My TAB partner drew a silly monster on the
black board as an example, we then asked the children to draw their own
monster. Shortly there after we realized the children were simply copying the
monster from the black board. When we erased the monster from the board the
children had a shocked look on their face like “How are we supposed to draw a
monster “right” without a model?” It feels like French childhood is something
to grow out of rather than something to celebrate. Sometimes this placement
feels like an exercise in “what not to do”. I do enjoy being here though, it
makes me appreciate the idea of inquiry and how accepted it is in Canada. I
appreciate the Canadian approach to diversity and inclusion even more every
time I see a child being physically removed from his desk for being
“disruptive”. I have yet to feel as though any “behaviours” that I encounter deserve being kicked out of the
classroom. Teaching here has made me cherish patience.
France has
already impacted my teaching style. I have been asked to create work sheets for
the children, in order to reinforce the language concepts. In the ECE program,
if any of my lesson plans included a work sheet I would be encouraged if not
demanded to re-think my lesson. Sure, work sheets sound like a terrible idea
when you consider the options available to teaching but actually seeing the
impact that work sheets have on children is a powerful reason to avoid them
like the plague. In one of our first lessons using a work sheet, my TAB partner
and I walked into the class and told them that we had a work sheet for them and
the six year olds literally groaned at the thought of completing another work
sheet. It is clear that six year olds know how little they actually engage with
the concepts by completing a work sheet. Is there a reason that teachers force
worksheets on the students that I do not understand?
A major
recurring theme for me has been the impact that TAB is having on my perception
of ELL children in my classroom. I have a new and profound respect for them, I
live as a French Language Learner adult on a daily basis and it is exhausting.
I have to focus all my energy on understanding what is being asked of me, and
then I have to work even harder to get my words across. I am grateful whenever
I see my TAB partner teacher again after a French interaction, I have taken
English and my ability to communicate for granted. This placement has given me
insight into a how an ELL student struggles. I think about the ELL students in
my placement last semester and I can appreciate the effort that they made to
answer my questions, ask questions of their own, chat with their friends and
generally understand the language used in the classroom. I imagine when they
went home they were exhausted and grateful for their native language used by
their family.
|
Walking through the town during Carnival with some of my students |
French
culture is opening my eyes to Canadian culture. I feel as though Canadian
culture is very subtle, it’s description is elusive, one must leave it to truly
understand what it is. Before coming to France
I felt as though other countries were full of culture and rich in traditions
and that Canada
fell short, but now, trying to adapt to French culture I am made aware of all
the things that make Canada Canada. Canada is in fact full of culture. Take
for a small example, a typical restaurant experience: In Canada someone greets
you at the door and takes you to a table. The server quickly returns with a
menu, drops it silently and then leaves. The server returns and asks what you
would like to drink, then returns with the drinks, usually accompanied by a glass
of water. After the server asks what you would like to eat, then returns with
the courses of food. During the meal the server frequents the table to ensure
the drinks are full and the food is hot. When the meal is finished the plates
are cleared and more drinks are offered along with dessert. If more drinks are
ordered the bill stays open and the drinks flow freely. If the meal is over
then the bill is brought and the server returns shortly to inquire if a debit
machine is needed. However all of this very simple restaurant routine is turned
upside down on it’s head in France.
In France
patrons are expected to seat themselves and at the very least choose the
desired table. The server asks if you are expecting to eat a meal or just
stopping in for a drink. If you just order a drink, the beverage is brought to
you along with the bill. If you order a meal the meal is brought out, not
necessarily accompanied with all the meal but whatever is hot at that time. The
server does not return until the meal is over. The server clears the table and
then asks if dessert or cheese and coffee are in order. If the meal is over the
server promptly leaves until the patron signals (mysteriously so) that the bill
is desired. It is expected that euros are used and credit cards are the
exception. Eating out can be a stressful experience, especially if you are on a
time line and do not know how to ask for a bill. By having to adapt to a new culture it has
made me more aware of the challenges that students who are new to Canada are
constantly dealing with. They not only have to deal with a language barrier
they also need to learn the way in which Canadians live. From the moment they
step outside the safety of their home things change and they are bombarded with
Canadian culture.
Finally
this experience is teaching me a lot about myself. The things that I need, the
things I can live without and the things that make me happy. I have learnt that
this is an extremely stressful environment for me to live and work in. I don’t
understand French enough to feel 100% confident in my translations and my
command of the language is even less than my comprehension. Not knowing French
makes navigating the culture even more difficult, I cannot necessarily ask
questions that I need to or be able to explain myself when I do something
un-French. All of this combined means that my body and my mind are constantly
under stress. And being outside of my normal environment and stressed means
that I don’t cope with the stress as well as I would if I was at home. It’s
taken me this long for me to realize that I need time to myself, time that is
perfectly quiet where I can be alone with my thoughts. And on top of needing
time to myself I need to run, and I need to run a lot. I run at home, I don’t
know why I thought I could get away without it here. Running provides me with
an outlet, a time to myself, time to think if I want or time to zone out and it
lets me work the daily accumulated stress out of my body and off my mind.
Running is crucial to my wellbeing. When I return home I will be better
equipped to take care of me. Healthy body means healthy teacher, healthy
teacher means vibrant teacher and vibrant teacher means vibrant classroom.
|
We turned the corner and VOILA |
|
It gets more and more intricate the closer you get |
|
Kids are kids no matter where you are |
|
Normal looking street in Paris |
|
Its a 10 lane round-about, a death trap |
|
Getting closer to the Tower |
|
Rocking the old architecture |
|
How would you find anyone at the train station? |
|
Our first meal together in our apartment |
|
Typical classroom |
|
They chop the trees down once the start blocking the sun |
|
The river in St. Pierre les Nemours |
|
The castle of Nemours |
|
Sitting above the castle sewage drain |
|
South view of the castle |
|
The school where Courtney and I are placed |
Travel Log
My name is Tara Kerr and I am
currently placed in a small town in France,
St. Pierre les
Nemours. The school is very small, less than 200 students and would be
considered extremely traditional by Canadian standards. I chose TAB because of
the adventure that it promised. Initially I thought it would provide an opportunity
for my husband and I to travel to new places. And in terms of a semester in Calgary versus a semester
abroad, the latter was extremely enticing. I had always studied French in school
and I thought that going to a French speaking country would be undoubtedly
helpful in gaining more language.
Getting to the point where I had
a flight booked was a long and extremely onerous process. In the beginning the
TAB placements available seemed endless but then as the process unfolded they disappeared
one by one. My TAB interview was difficult, I was nervous to begin with and it
turns out that I had to interview with another TAB applicant, it felt like a
competition of worldliness. It was discussed at the interview that France was no
longer an option because there was no contract. Then the waiting, and waiting
and waiting and waiting, there was always something to wait for. However in the
process of waiting, my husband and I discussed that TAB wasn’t right for us and
so I had resigned myself to not going. Then Laurie called and said “surprise!”
A France
placement was available and would I like it? I told her no. Geoff, my husband,
immediately sensed my disappointment and we discussed whether or not it truly
was possible. I called Laurie back that night and I told her yes. Then more
waiting. A contract still hadn’t come through but everyone was optimistic about
receiving one. Laurie gave us very little information, simply because she
didn’t know very much. She said she didn’t want to muddy the waters with
questions when we still hadn’t received a contract. So we waited, with no idea
what the placement would look like. December passed with still no contract and
no more information. The first week in January came and went and still no contract.
At the end of the second week in January Laurie wrote us and gave us the
disheartening news that France
was no longer an option because she hadn’t heard anything and classes had
begun. She gave us the option of arranging a placement on our own, but we only
had a week to get everything in order. By this time I was exhausted from the
emotional roller coaster and I opted out. I felt that maybe France wasn’t in God’s plan for me, I was going
to stay in Calgary.
I was not upset by this choice, I didn’t want to leave Geoff in the first
place, thinking about living without my husband for several months sounds less
than ideal. In the third week of January, Laurie called again, I was getting
used to the fact that everytime Laurie called something disastrous or
miraculous would occur. She let us know that a contract had come in, earlier in
January except there was a lot of confusion around it, she thought the contract
was for the south of France students and the French liasons thought the
contract was for all of the France students. I had no idea what to do, I prayed
and I prayed hard! I was going to France, then I wasn’t and now I could;
I didn’t know what God wanted for me. I decided to go, and then the race was on
to get everything ready in about 10 days. A small feat.
I did quite a bit of preparing for
the trip because I thought I was going for a long time before the trip fell
through and then reappeared like a Phoenix.
I visited the pharmacy to get my flu shot and inquire about any vaccinations
that I need for Europe, but France
is epidemic free! I then notified the pharmacist that I would need several
months of my current prescriptions for my trip. I also made an appointment with
my doctor to discuss just little things that had been bothering me for a while.
France
demanded I have perfect health! Then I started gathering French resources and
literature for the assignments. I placed holds on all the learn-to-speak-French
cd’s at the library, I then downloaded them to my ipod for all my runs and
workout sessions. I also borrowed some books about Paris itself. I found one book written by
photographer who lived in Paris after WW2, it
was beautiful and gave me a good sense of where Paris has come from since then. Not to
mention the fact I love looking at and taking photos.
Before booking our flights the
other girls in the placement and I met at a Starbucks to meet each other and
try to plan our first few days together. Its difficult planning a trip so
important with people you don’t know. Its hard to just make a decision when you
don’t know how other people will react. Nevertheless we finally agreed on a
hotel and booked it. To book a flight I
met with my Mom, squeezing our meeting together in between our work shifts was a
small scheduling miracle. We met at a McDonalds in somewhere close to where we
were and then where we had to be later that night. Choosing a flight was really
tricky because there were four of us going and we wanted to at least arrive on
the same day if not travel together, not to mention trying to get a good deal
with the best possible connections taking into consideration jet lag. It turns
out we didn’t actually travel together or arrive at the same time. We had three
different flights between the four of us! I wanted the girls who arrived before
me to meet me at the train station. I planned on travelling out of the airport
and to the station by myself but I wanted the comfort of someone I recognized
with me as I tried to make my way to the hotel. Little did we know that
attempting to meet each other at Gare de Lyon is like finding a needle in a
haystack, it has five platforms. I imagined a train station like the C-Train
station, not so! Along with sheer size of the station, my flight was delayed
and the girls didn’t have wifi to check the status of my flight. So they
arrived at the station on time, but I wouldn’t show up for two more hours. I tried looking for them when I arrived at the
station and realized that there was no way I would find them even if they were
there. I miraculously found the hotel we booked by literally choosing a
direction to walk in. Instantly, when I walked into the lobby the concierge
knew who I was and who I was looking for without even asking her. I finally
found the girls, things were about to get a little bit easier.
.
No one
could have prepared me for what the hotel looked like. The elevator is smaller
than the size of a porta-potty. It’s not actually meant for people with
luggage, it fits about one person with one piece of luggage. Then there are no
floors to choose from you, pick half a floor, like 3.5 and then either walk up
to 4 or down to 3. The hallways aren’t necessarily symmetrical, they are
narrower at some points and wider at others, not to mention that they are
barely wide enough for one piece of luggage to be wheeled behind you. I assume
not all hotels are like this, and in truth the hotels we went to were both
super old.
Nothing I did before leaving for France could
have actually prepared me for the past few days that I’ve been here. Arriving
in a strange country without actually speaking the language is so challenging.
Trying to navigate a city without a map, or without wi-fi and without a friend
is something I don’t actually want to do again. There isn’t a manual that
explains how to adjust to living with four complete strangers. Nor is there
much to do to figure out how to live without your husband. I’ve lived without
my family before, I’ve moved to a different country without my family, but it’s
not the same, moving away from your husband, someone I decided to live the rest
of my life with. I’m not prepared for this. I want this, but I’m not prepared
for this. Hopefully it’ll get easier with time, as I develop deeper and more
meaningful relationship with the girls, when it’s less about survival and more
about enjoying each other.
How awesome is your blog! Nicely done. Greg
ReplyDeleteJust think, if you didn't have to be in school, life be grand there in France! I hate it when you guys put pictures of food in your journals - as a well described foodaholic, it is killing me.
ReplyDeleteYour description of the factory model of education rings true for all of the French students. I am glad you are gaining an appreciation for our own system while abroad, but, recognize that not all classrooms here will live up to the standards you may aspire to. There may be a mind set brought on by the church that permeates all of interactions with youth in the country. In my opinion, they may believe that kids are evil and that they must be punished in order to beat the evil out of them. In Canada, for the most part, kids are considered good, and it is only behaviors that may be questionable (hardly to the point of being considered evil, however). Just my two bits as I ponder the situation (okay, babble on about nothing).
Your questions about worksheets can be answered simply by saying that when teachers believe they are responsible to be the transmitters of all knowledge, then a worksheet simplifies that transmission and gives the teacher a false sense of adequately covering the material. When you realize that you are not the transmitter, but rather the facilitator, your thoughts about worksheets changes. However, sometimes worksheets are useful when you have to drill certain skills, say, like learning how to name compounds in chemistry. On the whole, however, they are only one way to help kids learn, and not the best way.
I think that appreciating the ELL students in your classes is a great lesson for you. In Calgary, this can be nothing but beneficial for your future.
I, too, would have a tough time defining Canadian culture, and if I did, I am sure it would be one of the past, not the present. I must admit that we are much more time conscious than most, and therefore when time is being wasted, we get excited more readily than others. Again, bla bla bla.
I can appreciate what it would be like living with three other girls for you as I have three women in my family. I am lucky, however, because I have the dungeon in the basement for refuge. As I abhor running, I am glad that you find this a good escape from the minutia that can wear you out in an apartment being shared with three others.
Nemours looks incredible, and if you return there in the future, you will be able to tell everyone of your experiences there nostalgically like it was a dream. Enjoy your last few weeks.